Sunday, 26 February 2023
Major Michel's 'Trevor Hastinges or the Battle of Tewkesbury' 1842
Friday, 24 February 2023
Major Michel's 'Henry of Monmouth or the Field of Agincourt' 1841
Thursday, 9 February 2023
Matthew Sturgis' 'Passionate Attitudes' 1995
Sunday, 29 January 2023
Martin Meredith's 'The State of Africa' 2005
- SETETSE KHAMA (Botswana - was Bechuanaland). There are only four references in the book: Botswana provided a rare example of an African state that used its bonanza of mineral riches wisely...corruption hardly existed; Botswana stood out as an example of a liberal democracy, tolerant of opposition activity, where the rule of law was held in respect and where economic development proceeded apace;(sadly) Botswana has the highest infection rate in the world, more than 37% of its population of 1.6 million are HIV-positive; in the age group of 15-49, the infection rate is 40%. By 2010 life expectancy in Botswana is expected to fall to 27 years; half of all children in the country are likely to be Aids orphans; Botswana stands out as a unique example of an enduring multi-party democracy with a record of sound economic management, that has used its diamond riches for national advancement and maintained an administration free of corruption. I would have liked to have heard more about this from the author; above all, WHY? In 2023, Botswana is the least corrupt country in Africa and ranks just below Portugal and South Korea (Transparency International)
- NELSON MANDELA Somewhere Over The Rainbow. Mandela stands out as a Beacon of what might have been and what could be. Unique, remarkable, awe-inspiring. A GREAT 'Mr Big'!
- GAMAL ABDEL NASSER (Egypt) triumphs during the first years in power were followed by a catalogue of disappointments and disasters...he quarrelled constantly with other Arab governments, retreating more and more into isolation...yet whatever disasters befell Egypt, Nasser never lost his popularity with the masses.
- JOMO KENYATTA (Kenya) enjoyed massive authority. Even critics of his government accorded him due respect...he adhered to capitalist policies, encouraging both indigenous private enterprise and foreign investment...he was ruthless in dealing with any challenge to his authority
- JULIUS NYERE (Tanzania) socialist experiment stood out as a beacon of hope...he became the most influential thinker and writer in Africa of his time...took on the drive for socialism virtually single-handedly...between 1973 and 1977 some 11 million people were placed in new villages, in what amounted to the largest mass movement in Africa's history...there were numerous reports of coercion and brutality...by the end of the 1970s Tanzania was in dire straits...what progress was made was financed largely by foreign aid... He stepped down voluntarily, after 23 in power.
- LEOPOLD SENGHOR ( (Senegal) a centralised system of groundnut management soon became bogged down in incompetence and corruption...Senghor steered through these difficulties with a mixture of compromise, coercion and pork-barrel politics. He was one of the few (6 out of 150) to relinquish power voluntarily, after 20 years in office.
- SAMORA MACHEL (Mozambique). I would have liked much more comment on Machel. The little there is about him in the book suggests he was a skilful pragmatist.
- KENNETH KAUNDA (Zambia) was equally adamant about the merits of one-party rule and his own leadership, despite a catastrophic record of economic mismanagement over 25 years in office. I recall him for his hair quiff, his large white hankie and his predilection for weeping in public!
- KWAME NKRUMAH (Ghana) No other country demonstrated the decline of Africa so graphically as Ghana. Although a few countries in the continent were independent before 1957 (Liberia, South Africa, Egypt, Ethiopia, Libya, Tunisia, Morocco), the British colony of Gold Coast becoming the independent Ghana was seen as a trailblazer, as was its new leader Nkrumah. Meredith heads his early chapter on Ghana, The Gold Coast Experiment, and a later one on Nkrumah Feet of Clay. Tragically, it now feels like an experiment in dictatorship, and worse, which was to be replicated throughout the dark continent.
- ABEID KARUME (Zanzibar). His regime was bizarre and vindictive from the outset...the Revolutionary Council ordered arrests, imprisonment without trial, torture and execution as it saw it.
- JEAN-BEDEL BOKASSA (Central African Republic) combined not only greed and personal violence but delusions of grandeur unsurpassed by any other African leader...he also gained a reputation for cannibalism...
- MILTON OBOTE (Uganda) in common with many other African leaders, he set his sights on establishing a one-party state, arguing that tribal and factional groupings tended to threaten the stability of the country...his style of government became increasingly secretive and autocratic.
- HASTINGS BANDA (Malawi) his dictatorship degenerated into tyranny...incarcerating thousands of Malawians in detention centres
- JOSEPH MOBUTU (Zaire). The Congo/Zaire, with Rwanda, Burundi, truly represent Hearts of Darkness and Mobutu one of the worst of tyrants. Amazingly, he lasted so long. But as with so many other corrupt leaders, he lasted thanks to outsiders' support; in this case, the USA who, with France, Belgium, Britain, Russia and China, could not leave Africa alone. Their dirty fingerprints are all over this tragic 50 years - for plunder, Great Power rivalry, weaponry profits. The UN Secretary-General, Boutros Boutros-Ghali does not come out of things smelling of roses, either.
- IDI AMIN (Uganda) organised death squads to hunt down and kill scores of army and police officers...within a few months, mass killing of Langi and Acholi began. 'It was impossible to dispose of the bodies in graves'...thousands died at the hands of his special squads. No one was immune.
- FRANCISCO MACIAS NGUEMA (Equatorial Guinea) steadily sank into a morass of murder and mayhem...thousands were incarcerated in prison and murdered there...many were executed on a whim...out of a population of 3000,000, at least 50,000 had been killed and 125,000 had fled into exile.
- MENGISTU HAILE MARIAM (Ethiopia) thousands died in the red terror, thousands more were imprisoned, many were tortured and beaten
- ROBERT MUGABE (Zimbabwe). The author correctly heads the chapter on Mugabe's seizure of, and maintenance of, power in Southern Rhodesia/Zimbabwe, as A Degree in Violence. Perhaps it was because his regime started later (1980) than most of the others, the fact that it was a British colony, that much of the terror was aimed at whites and the growth of more intrusive media to report everything, leads one to feel his rule was one of the most tyrannical and repulsive of all. He fought the war not to achieve democracy but to gain total control...by the end of the 1990s Zimbabwe was in dire straits. In 2003, he warned he would use even worse violence if necessary. 'If that is Hitler, then let me be a Hitler tenfold. Ten times. That is what we stand for'.
Friday, 20 January 2023
Thomas Pakenham's 'The Scramble for Africa' 1991
- as with India and elsewhere, it is nearly incredible that so few controlled so many. Whether it was Britain, Germany, France, Italy, Portugal or the King of the Belgians, each used a tiny amount of Europeans to lead exploration or establish and run colonies
- not until the late 1870s was there a real push to colonise rather than to trade (whether it be precious metals, ivory, rubber, oil, cocoa etc.) Only in the next two decades did the coastal forts and settlements expand up rivers (Niger, Congo etc) in pursuit of economic gain and, thanks to David Livingstone, Christian missionising (The Flag follows the Cross).
- the Scramble - above all between Britain and France and then, later, Germany, was led as much by individuals 'on the ground' - H.M. Stanley, Carl Peters, Frederick Lugard, George Goldie, Cecil Rhodes, Pierre Brazza, Jean-Baptiste Marchand - as by governments (although imperialists such as Joe Chamberlain and Gambetta were only too ready to support the intrepid explorers/colonists). Some leaders, such as Gladstone and Lord Granville, were usually opposed to any expansion; even Lord Salisbury was ambivalent. Others, like Bismarck, changed their minds about colonies. Apart from the strategic race for the Nile, the running had been left to individuals: enterprising capitalists such as Cecil Rhodes and George Goldie, humanitarians such as Lugard and Mackinnon, eccentric naturalists such as Harry Johnston.
- The brutality of all races, including the various African tribes, was shocking (and still is).
- Whilst there were clearly some genuine, upright, god-fearing missionaries, some were hand-in-glove with the dreadful behaviour of their secular compatriots - none worse than the silence of the Baptists and Roman Catholics in the Congo.
- the single-mindedness and bravery of the explorers and military officers was astounding. So many Europeans lost their lives in all the spheres - West, East, Central and South Africa - killed in battles, skirmishes, ambushes and, above all, diseases. For every well-known name - the Stanleys, Gordons, Marchands, Goldies, Wolseleys - there was a myriad of others, a few with memorial plaques on church walls back home, but most lost to the jungle etc. or, worse, eaten by cannibalistic tribes.
- the 'origin' of the Union of South Africa explains everything about its later tragic years.
- As for King Leopold of the Belgians - you need to read the book. No words here can sum up the evil done in his name, usually knowingly. Yet he died in his bed.
- (Uganda) Of all the freelance imperialists who promoted the Scramble, Lugard was to prove the most tenacious and, ultimately, the most successful. In the next forty years no other proconsul would put such a powerful moral stamp on the character of European rule in Africa. Significantly, both his parents were missionaries, and his hero was David Livingstone. Yet he had sailed for Africa more to cast away his life than to build an empire.
- (German East Africa) Carl Peters was said to model himself on Nietzche's 'Superman'...not for him the usual euphemisms about the importance of 'firmness' and the regrettable need for 'vigorous measures'. He bragged to his readers about his 'exultation' as he shot down any African bold enough to oppose him, and boasted of the trail of destruction he had left along the valley of the Tana...
- (German South-West Africa) ...the station officer at Jaune, Lieutenant Schenneman, who had taken a black mistress, heard rumours of her affairs with three Africans. He told his black servant to castrate the three men. The servant mistook his instructions, marched off with a party of soldiers and castrated the first three men he met in a nearby village. On another occasion, a Lieutenant Dominik was sent on an expedition to negotiate a treaty with the Bahoro. Instead, he shot down all the men and women in the village, and the fifty-four children that survived were put in baskets and drowned like kittens.
- (Cecil Rhodes) These years between 1886 and 1890 were the most astonishing of Rhodes's astonishing life. It was as though he had been given the magical power to live four careers simultaneously and they were all telescoped into those four years. In Kimberley he was the Great Amalgamator, the Bismarck of the diamond mines. In Johannesburg astride the Rand gold-mines, he was a pioneer of goldbugs and Randlords. At the Cape he was the august Prime Minister of Cape Colony, trusted by both Afrikaners and the English-speaking community. Across the Limpopo he was to be a new kind of colonial imperialist, outflanking all rivals, Boers, Germans and Portuguese, as he pushed up into Mashonaland and the north.
Saturday, 31 December 2022
Robert Peston's 'The Whistle Blower' 2021
Wednesday, 28 December 2022
John Sutherland's 'Mrs Humphry Ward' 1990
The other deleterious aspect was her 'men'. Her father, Tom Arnold (Dr Arnold of Rugby's second son) would these days be accused of cruelty to his eldest daughter Mary. Up until her mid teens she rarely saw him, being shoved off to various schools while her siblings mainly enjoyed the comforts of a home life. He vacillated between Anglicanism and Catholicism (Newman was there to tempt him) and comes across as a thoroughly selfish man. If he was second rate, then Mary's husband Thomas Humphry Ward (1845-1926) was third rate, spending his life working for The Times as their Art critic, whilst dabbling in purchases of Old Masters (more often than not being bamboozled or bamboozling himself). For much of their marriage, and increasingly so, he sponged off his wife's earnings. There was worse to come: Mary's only son, Arnold Sandwith Ward (1876-1950) was a fourth-rater. An inveterate gambler, often worse for drink, every position or job (the Army, the House of Commons) his mother's influence gained for him was to prove disastrous. In the end, her husband's spendthrift ways and her son's gambling, meant Mary Ward had to keep churning out books to pay for them. No wonder, Arnold's cousins, the Huxleys, and his younger sister Janet (who married G.M. Trevelyan) came to dislike him intensely. There are few heroes or heroines. The ones that stick out are Mary's eldest child, Dorothy (1874-1964), who never married and who spent her life supporting her mother and trying to minimise the malodorous effect of her brother; George Smith and his son-in-law Reginald Smith, of the publishing house Smith, Elder were not only to be her publishers but her benefactors and saviours on many occasions. Not only did the benefit from her successes but they kept faith with her during the remorseless decline in standards (and sales) from the 1900s onwards.
The tragedy of Mary Ward's career (and she is not alone as an author in this) is that she fell out of fashion. The American book-buying public made her name (from Robert Elsmere onwards for some dozen years), but they lost interest in her type of novel as the 20th century dawned. From 1900, she wrote some good novels, and some good characters and descriptions in the not-so-good works. But one gets the feeling that they had to be written to keep the creditors at bay - the town house and Stocks, the country mansion, the incessant needs of husband and son, were only dealt with by her churning out book after book. She was briefly a useful propogandist during the Great War (egged on by the ex-USA President Roosevelt and others), but her general work was long past its sell-by date.
Mary Ward's work in supporting or setting up University Hall, Marchmont Hall and then the Passmore Edwards Settlement in Tavistock Square certainly deserved more than a measly CBE. THE PES proved a boon not only for the Working Class and children with the Vacation schools, but also for hundreds of handicapped children, as 'special' schools were developed round London. The debit side is filled with Mary Ward's major involvement in the Anti-Suffrage League. She launched the Anti-Suffrage Review in December 1908, led an anti-suffrage deputation to the Prime Minister Asquith in June 1910, and ensured her son championed the cause once he was elected to Parliament. It is a strange course as her own life and activities (surrounded by second-rate men) surely should have suggested that women were at least men's equal.
Virginia Woolf made a typically shrewish remark in her diary, on hearing of Mary Ward's death: Mrs Ward is dead; poor Mrs Humphrey Ward; and it appears that she was merely a woman of straw after all - shovelled into the grave and already forgotten. Unfeeling, but with more than a grain of truth in it. I like to think it is also true of Virginia Woolf.
I will probably look out for three more of Mary Ward's books - Marcella (1894), Lady Connie (1916), and her memoir A Writer's Recollections (1918). However, I have large pile of books on my Study floor looking at me accusingly. Their needs will be attended to first.






