My Top 10 Ricardian (Richard III) Fiction and Non-Fiction Books

The Richard III Society's quarterly publication - The Ricardian Bulletin - latest Spring Issue landed on my doorstep this morning. Highlighted on the cover was the article on The greatest Ricardian reads of all Time' - 50 Fiction and 50 Non-Fiction. These were judged by a panel of twenty 'eminent' Historians, including me! Inevitably subjective, it was fascinating to read the lists and compare them with my own offerings. I counted 28 novels on the list of 50 Fiction written this century; just over half - four in the top ten. Some of those 28 I had never heard of! My most recent novel chosen is as long ago as 1982. Where we did agree was putting the same three in the top four, albeit in a slightly different order.

MY Fiction top ten (with their position in the Society's overall List in brackets)

1.  Rosemary Hawley Jarman - We Speak No Treason 1971 (No. 3)

2. Sharon Kay Penman - The Sunne in Splendour 1982 (No.2)

3. Patrick Carleton - Under the Hog 1938 (No. 8)

4. Josephine Tey - The Daughter of Time 1951 (No. 1)

5. G.P. R. James - The Woodman 1849 (No. 27=)

6. Rhoda Edwards - Some Touch of Pity 1977 (No. 4)

7=. Marian Palmer - The White Boar 1968 (No. 13)

7=. Carola Oman - Crouchback 1929 (No. 49=)

7=. Marjorie Bowen - Dickon 1929 (No. 33)

7=. Mary Sturge Gretton - Crumplin' 1932 (No. 49=)

Clearly, no one else had probably heard of, let alone read, Crouchback or Crumplin', as they both scored a grand total of 2.5, compared with Josephine Tey's The Daughter of Time, which racked up 111 votes. I was actually surprised that James' The Woodman garnered 6 votes. Good old William Shakespeare managed to come in at No. 12, with a score of 19 votes. Interestingly, Scott Mariani's The Tudor Deception (2023) made the top 10 and received 24 votes.

As for the Non-Fiction - again, there were major differences between my list and the Ricardian panel's. I eschewed the most recent, rather controversial ones. Seeing who was on the panel, I realised these books were bound to figure, two in the top five.

1. Charles Ross - Richard III 1981/1999 (No. 6)

2. David Horspool - Richard III: A Ruler and his Reputation 2015 (No. 31=)

3. Rosemary Horrox - Richard III: A Study in Service 1989 (No. 4)

4. Caroline Halstead - Richard III 1844 (No. 14)

5. Michael Hicks - Richard III: The Self-Made King 2019 (No. 9=)

6. Paul Murray Kendall - Richard III 1955 (No. 1)

7. ed. James Petrie - Richard III. Crown and People 1985 (No. 36=)

8. Jeremy Potter - Good King Richard? 1984 (No.2)

9. Anne Sutton and Peter Hammond - The Coronation of Richard III 1983 (No. 9=)

10. Anne Curry and Glen Foard - Bosworth 1485 (Not on the list!)

I had thought of putting James Gairdner's Richard III on my list, but I am not surprised that it failed to make the top 50.  I was surprised that Clements Markham was second to last, at No.49, but not to see three of John Ashdown-Hills's books there - (at least Rosemary Horrox equalled this). After all, the list was compiled by Ricardians.  Also, it was The Greatest Reads, not the most sound History books; hence Kendall was bound to come out top.